Agree 100% - No to Daniel Smith and no to a Forever Canadian party. When I heard the Premier say the referendum gave her a mandate to demand more control over immigration - with a scant 50+ %, I realized we are dealing with the same far-right-pandering politician. And don’t get me started on her party and caucus’ attack on Nenshi. Rant over. Radicalized.
He may be lame, but he’s nowhere close to being on his way out. 2 years is a long time. He’s done alot of damage in his first 2years, it’s wishful thinking to assume he won’t do as much if not more damage with the time he has left. That’s if he actually doesn’t try to run in 2028.
I wouldn’t say becoming an ardent supporter of a party or taking it further to be a candidate means you’ve been radicalized. That seems to be the natural progression of advocacy.
I’m so radicalized against Danielle Smith and the UCP that I can’t even listen to them speak!
I am tired of focusing on the mess that is Alberta health services. It is immobilizing, we need a positive approach that can be communicated quickly. Health is for people to use to act freely for themselves and their nation. Without it we have tyranny.
Jane did you write that incredible piece I read this morning? I have long admired Dr. Parks. Our universal Healthcare is non partisan issue if there ever has been one. Human beings require healthcare. It should not be limited to the richest amongst us. We see what the US Medicare system costs each person individually as a system designed to enrich insurance providers. Over $2,000-$2,500 US paid a month, $500 monthly increases annually to the time of thousands year over year. Add to that the deductible often in the $8,000 range per a lowest coverage plan. That huge payout does not even guarantee you coverage as your claim can be denied. Often people with pre-existimg conditions cannot even get insurance coverage. The fact Smith is working so hard to try to convince Albertans and other Canadians outside this province that privatization (profitization) is the only path this is about enriching the lobbyists and insurance providers. No one at this point should place any trust in Smith nor the UCP. The UCP have proven over the last 7 years they do not have the best interest of Albertans in mind re anything they do. They are consummate liars. They are immoral, inept, unethical and corrupt. Dr. Parks and another doctor (Dr. Karina Patel?) have recently joined the NDP. They know how healthcare can be improved and remain functioning as universal healthcare. Under the UCP, we taxpayers are not paying for healthcare access for ourselves. We are paying to allow the wealthy to queue jump while we get pushed further down the line. This is the system the UCP created. A cancer diagnosis requires timely surgery within 6 weeks of diagnosis. Under the UCP model that no longer occurs. It is now 9 months out. By then your cancer has spread further, resulting in a poorer prognosis re life span and requiring far more treatment that perhaps could have been avoided if treated at early stage/tumour growth and spread. Cancer is costly even with universal healthcare due to loss of income add in medications required by the patient. In the US a lumpectomy surgery two years ago was $100,000 US. That does not include the subsequent chemo, radiation and targetted therapy Herceptin if HER-2 positive. Albertans simply accepting what lying Smith and her regime is saying based on zero knowledge is so wrong and just plain ignorant. Never sign a contract without researching the the impact. Not reading the fine print as they say is dangerous as they sat as the devil is in the details not the media spin. What is coming as well re how she is going to end up giving away our oil to oil and gas is yet another betrayal of Albertans. Also she has given away why she wants the head tax on TFW’s because at the behest of oil and gas who own her they want more TFW’s vs Alberta unionized workers to undercut unionized Alberta trade workers to lower oil and gas’ employment costs at their behest. She is likely planning on flooding Alberta with TFW’s. With Smith one can see the dots being connected if one is paying attention. This was shared in a very interesting interview based on another recent statement by Smith that Energi Media (YouTube) discussed with Gil McGowan (AFL header) on Nov 11. Alberta trade workers be on alert. Smith is not on your side. When an industry puts their lobbyist in office as Premier nothing will ever be for the benefit of the taxpayer.
Hi Kay. I actually wrote this over the last three days. It takes time to come up with the actual story. I have always thought that you need to "take the reader by the hand". This is going to 18 health care decision makers, both Canadian and Albertan. I am also trying in my bumbling way to get it out to ordinary frustrated people. I believe that a two pronged approach to this war is required. 1) we need to erase the mess but 2) we need all citizens to understand why health care is nonnegotiable - and that is because it provides us with "freedom to act" and is therefore nation building.
Yes you do need to take them by the hand in this province. Not everyone can connect the dots especially when they have mistakenly put their trust in people who are fundamentally untrustworthy and have proven so over and over again. Smith stating smoking is good for your health, vaccines bad but ivermectin good, cancer patients responsible for their cancer are not words that in-still confidence or faith in the speaker’s intelligence nor judgement. Her 2021 policy paper stating Albertans need to get used to paying for their healthcare was aggregious.
An articulate and convincing summary of http://just.how horrific it is to live in Alberta with the UPCs and Smith. As a former educator I now have to deal with the horrific announcement from non educators determining that high school education graduate requirements should be.lowered ! Another devastating government decision that can't be ignored !!
The sheer obvious guilt shown by her refusal to hold a public inquiry into corrupt care is where it started for me. Heard she’s getting into dentistry and pharmaceuticals? Is Sam opening a new division? She’s garbage and I’m definitely supporting NDP.
I was still hoping the institution would hold up; cabinet, caucus, even membership itself. I just finally ran out of any reason to think that it would.
He can be— if he decides to speak to them. Danielle Smith is wrong that Albertans have different priorities— they have different preferences, but I think they have very, very similar priorities.
I agree, and hope that he will get beyond the cliches. But in terms of fundamental values, he and the NDP are at least persuadable to do the right things. Smith, as she admitted in a debate with me in Alberta Views magazine in 2018, is a follower of Ayn Rand. For those who haven't read Rand, that means that she has disdain for most of the population and thinks that there is a very small group of corporate geniuses in whose hands we should always put our fate. She is demonstrating that she believes that in her refusal to even have an environmental assessment of Kevin O'Leary's monstrous hyperscale data centre, or Gina Rinehart's monstrous Rocky Mountains coal mine, and in her handing over of much of our healthcare to businessman Sam Mraiche who has no more background in healthcare than the premier herself. Add to that her cover-up of the surgical contracts and the surreal Turkish Tylenol rip-off and it's obvious that Smith is not just a believer in unregulated capitalist rule but also almost certainly a bribe-taking thief.
That was a strength of Rachel Notley as well— willing to be proven wrong. From the perspective of someone who always wants to be right, I’ve accepted that a willingness to be proven wrong is more valuable than being right.
Completely agree. I have lived and worked in Alberta for 69 years. I could never figure out why Albertans are so stubborn that they always vote conservative. There hasn’t been a leader of provincial conservatives worth voting for since Lougheed. Yet they persist. And Albertans are now paying the price because the party has been absconded by Project 2025 and yet people still can’t abandon that hill they think they need to die on. I honestly feel robbed. Like someone I have known for years reveals themselves as a thief and an abuser. The betrayal feels absolute. The corruption, the grift, the manipulation, the flip-flopping and the out and out lies while the UCP spends our tax money like a teen ager with mommy and daddy’s debit card. I never would have thought that I would be looking and begging for the NDP to save us from this dystopian nightmare. But we discovered that Notley’s NDP were honestly doing what was right for Albertan’s after decades of neglect. I truly hope that perhaps Albertans are now understanding of just how perilous our future is and we all need to get behind people that are compassionate, thoughtful and not driven by corrupted money or ideology. We need to save our healthcare. For once and for all get rid of parties that chronically diminish it. We need to work hard to keep the polluters out and make sure industry cleans up after itself. I am gobsmacked that the UCP put a moratorium on green energy projects and then turns around and give the tech industry the go ahead to power their facilities with fossil fuels and consume our ever precious water and electricity on our backs. We have been abandoned by the UCP.
I am tired of focusing on the mess that is Alberta health services. It is immobilizing, we need a positive approach that can be communicated quickly. Health is for people to use to act freely for themselves and their nation. Without it we have tyranny.
Let's see if the idea takes off and is effective. I am new at using this platform so a bit clunky.
The argument for universal care should be easy to make it saves money and provides better health benefits. Using public money for private healthcare undercuts public services and takes away funding from public services. Giving public money to private schools is that same thing. Private schools should be paid for with private money anything else is simply degrading the public system that we all rely on. We need to move to a more Finnish approach and get ride of private schools altogether. Rather than starving the public system. We need ro remember that public schools are producing the next generation of citizens who more than ever need critical thinking skills and problem solving skills.
Universal healthcare connects people and creates a sense of community. Privatisation drives alienation - b/c it says, in effect, ‘no-one cares about you; without wealth, you don't matter’.
Wow, Deidre! I sat down last night after summarizing my last year of writing and how it has shaped and reshaped me. I pushed that essay out this morning and then I read yours! I can’t help but think we’ve all hit a wall called the UCP FU; we’ll do whatever we want despite what the general populace says! I have not lost my fight, but I am tired of all the BS. Keep it up! I’m listening!
I appreciate your discussion on Smith’s “radicalization” of Albertans. If Dr. Parks is a strong, dedicated supporter of the cause of public, universal, free high quality, healthcare- adequately resourced, he is partisan. He warns we all should be unwilling to consider the alternative where those who can pay get preferential access. Smith is right- he is partisan to the cause of universal healthcare.
She’s the one who made this issue partisan by refusing to listen and adjust policy. Now the only way to influence government policy is to change the government.
100% agree! The UCP is a hot mess and getting messier. At this point the NDP is the best we’ve got. Dr. Parks just made it an even better choice in my opinion. He’s a hero. Thanks for your honesty and smart writing. I always look forward to seeing you in my inbox Deirdre
Demonstrating "an institutional unwillingness to correct its own course" is the best description of this UCP that I have ever heard. Have they ever once admitted fault? And I don't count mealy-mouthed apologies like the one from "Spanky" McAllister.
🙌 agreed whole heartedly - and the current machinations with the map and the laissez faire approach to this much gerrymandering proves this UCP government- literally through 140million dollars in the garbage. They have no intention of changing course, or listening to the citizenry of Alberta.
Agree 100% - No to Daniel Smith and no to a Forever Canadian party. When I heard the Premier say the referendum gave her a mandate to demand more control over immigration - with a scant 50+ %, I realized we are dealing with the same far-right-pandering politician. And don’t get me started on her party and caucus’ attack on Nenshi. Rant over. Radicalized.
Their video attacking Nenshi is so far over the line it's possibly libelous. But I'm not a lawyer.
Another way, she is so much like Trump. Doesn’t Danielle Smith know he’s lame, on his way out? I do not get her, at all.
He may be lame, but he’s nowhere close to being on his way out. 2 years is a long time. He’s done alot of damage in his first 2years, it’s wishful thinking to assume he won’t do as much if not more damage with the time he has left. That’s if he actually doesn’t try to run in 2028.
Agree, he’s not done yet, and who may replace Trump, may be even worse. Stephan Miller, or JD Vance.
I wouldn’t say becoming an ardent supporter of a party or taking it further to be a candidate means you’ve been radicalized. That seems to be the natural progression of advocacy.
I’m so radicalized against Danielle Smith and the UCP that I can’t even listen to them speak!
Beautiful. I agree wholeheartedly.
Privatizing health care has done it for me.
https://jane225o1.substack.com/p/the-north-star-of-public-health-what?r=1knw8f&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web
I am tired of focusing on the mess that is Alberta health services. It is immobilizing, we need a positive approach that can be communicated quickly. Health is for people to use to act freely for themselves and their nation. Without it we have tyranny.
Jane did you write that incredible piece I read this morning? I have long admired Dr. Parks. Our universal Healthcare is non partisan issue if there ever has been one. Human beings require healthcare. It should not be limited to the richest amongst us. We see what the US Medicare system costs each person individually as a system designed to enrich insurance providers. Over $2,000-$2,500 US paid a month, $500 monthly increases annually to the time of thousands year over year. Add to that the deductible often in the $8,000 range per a lowest coverage plan. That huge payout does not even guarantee you coverage as your claim can be denied. Often people with pre-existimg conditions cannot even get insurance coverage. The fact Smith is working so hard to try to convince Albertans and other Canadians outside this province that privatization (profitization) is the only path this is about enriching the lobbyists and insurance providers. No one at this point should place any trust in Smith nor the UCP. The UCP have proven over the last 7 years they do not have the best interest of Albertans in mind re anything they do. They are consummate liars. They are immoral, inept, unethical and corrupt. Dr. Parks and another doctor (Dr. Karina Patel?) have recently joined the NDP. They know how healthcare can be improved and remain functioning as universal healthcare. Under the UCP, we taxpayers are not paying for healthcare access for ourselves. We are paying to allow the wealthy to queue jump while we get pushed further down the line. This is the system the UCP created. A cancer diagnosis requires timely surgery within 6 weeks of diagnosis. Under the UCP model that no longer occurs. It is now 9 months out. By then your cancer has spread further, resulting in a poorer prognosis re life span and requiring far more treatment that perhaps could have been avoided if treated at early stage/tumour growth and spread. Cancer is costly even with universal healthcare due to loss of income add in medications required by the patient. In the US a lumpectomy surgery two years ago was $100,000 US. That does not include the subsequent chemo, radiation and targetted therapy Herceptin if HER-2 positive. Albertans simply accepting what lying Smith and her regime is saying based on zero knowledge is so wrong and just plain ignorant. Never sign a contract without researching the the impact. Not reading the fine print as they say is dangerous as they sat as the devil is in the details not the media spin. What is coming as well re how she is going to end up giving away our oil to oil and gas is yet another betrayal of Albertans. Also she has given away why she wants the head tax on TFW’s because at the behest of oil and gas who own her they want more TFW’s vs Alberta unionized workers to undercut unionized Alberta trade workers to lower oil and gas’ employment costs at their behest. She is likely planning on flooding Alberta with TFW’s. With Smith one can see the dots being connected if one is paying attention. This was shared in a very interesting interview based on another recent statement by Smith that Energi Media (YouTube) discussed with Gil McGowan (AFL header) on Nov 11. Alberta trade workers be on alert. Smith is not on your side. When an industry puts their lobbyist in office as Premier nothing will ever be for the benefit of the taxpayer.
Hi Kay. I actually wrote this over the last three days. It takes time to come up with the actual story. I have always thought that you need to "take the reader by the hand". This is going to 18 health care decision makers, both Canadian and Albertan. I am also trying in my bumbling way to get it out to ordinary frustrated people. I believe that a two pronged approach to this war is required. 1) we need to erase the mess but 2) we need all citizens to understand why health care is nonnegotiable - and that is because it provides us with "freedom to act" and is therefore nation building.
Yes you do need to take them by the hand in this province. Not everyone can connect the dots especially when they have mistakenly put their trust in people who are fundamentally untrustworthy and have proven so over and over again. Smith stating smoking is good for your health, vaccines bad but ivermectin good, cancer patients responsible for their cancer are not words that in-still confidence or faith in the speaker’s intelligence nor judgement. Her 2021 policy paper stating Albertans need to get used to paying for their healthcare was aggregious.
An articulate and convincing summary of http://just.how horrific it is to live in Alberta with the UPCs and Smith. As a former educator I now have to deal with the horrific announcement from non educators determining that high school education graduate requirements should be.lowered ! Another devastating government decision that can't be ignored !!
The sheer obvious guilt shown by her refusal to hold a public inquiry into corrupt care is where it started for me. Heard she’s getting into dentistry and pharmaceuticals? Is Sam opening a new division? She’s garbage and I’m definitely supporting NDP.
I was still hoping the institution would hold up; cabinet, caucus, even membership itself. I just finally ran out of any reason to think that it would.
Only thing is, is Nenshi up to the task of southern Alberta rural voters?
He can be— if he decides to speak to them. Danielle Smith is wrong that Albertans have different priorities— they have different preferences, but I think they have very, very similar priorities.
He needs energy too, his people need to have a strategy and get moving
Definitely.
I think he could but needs to put a lot of work in. He needs to stop putting down the UPC and talk about problem solving priorities with the people !!
I agree, and hope that he will get beyond the cliches. But in terms of fundamental values, he and the NDP are at least persuadable to do the right things. Smith, as she admitted in a debate with me in Alberta Views magazine in 2018, is a follower of Ayn Rand. For those who haven't read Rand, that means that she has disdain for most of the population and thinks that there is a very small group of corporate geniuses in whose hands we should always put our fate. She is demonstrating that she believes that in her refusal to even have an environmental assessment of Kevin O'Leary's monstrous hyperscale data centre, or Gina Rinehart's monstrous Rocky Mountains coal mine, and in her handing over of much of our healthcare to businessman Sam Mraiche who has no more background in healthcare than the premier herself. Add to that her cover-up of the surgical contracts and the surreal Turkish Tylenol rip-off and it's obvious that Smith is not just a believer in unregulated capitalist rule but also almost certainly a bribe-taking thief.
That was a strength of Rachel Notley as well— willing to be proven wrong. From the perspective of someone who always wants to be right, I’ve accepted that a willingness to be proven wrong is more valuable than being right.
I’m far removed from having any political savvy, but…
Notley was convinced that if she ran the tables in YEG & YYC, Bob’s her uncle? The NDP had their election HQ in Calgary.
They were going to be competitive in Calgary for sure. However, I wonder if Notley visited the charms of Brooks, Foremost, Bowman Island, etc?
Completely agree. I have lived and worked in Alberta for 69 years. I could never figure out why Albertans are so stubborn that they always vote conservative. There hasn’t been a leader of provincial conservatives worth voting for since Lougheed. Yet they persist. And Albertans are now paying the price because the party has been absconded by Project 2025 and yet people still can’t abandon that hill they think they need to die on. I honestly feel robbed. Like someone I have known for years reveals themselves as a thief and an abuser. The betrayal feels absolute. The corruption, the grift, the manipulation, the flip-flopping and the out and out lies while the UCP spends our tax money like a teen ager with mommy and daddy’s debit card. I never would have thought that I would be looking and begging for the NDP to save us from this dystopian nightmare. But we discovered that Notley’s NDP were honestly doing what was right for Albertan’s after decades of neglect. I truly hope that perhaps Albertans are now understanding of just how perilous our future is and we all need to get behind people that are compassionate, thoughtful and not driven by corrupted money or ideology. We need to save our healthcare. For once and for all get rid of parties that chronically diminish it. We need to work hard to keep the polluters out and make sure industry cleans up after itself. I am gobsmacked that the UCP put a moratorium on green energy projects and then turns around and give the tech industry the go ahead to power their facilities with fossil fuels and consume our ever precious water and electricity on our backs. We have been abandoned by the UCP.
Well said, Lori.
Courageous and authentic: Brava!
Thank you!
I am tired of focusing on the mess that is Alberta health services. It is immobilizing, we need a positive approach that can be communicated quickly. Health is for people to use to act freely for themselves and their nation. Without it we have tyranny.
Let's see if the idea takes off and is effective. I am new at using this platform so a bit clunky.
The argument for universal care should be easy to make it saves money and provides better health benefits. Using public money for private healthcare undercuts public services and takes away funding from public services. Giving public money to private schools is that same thing. Private schools should be paid for with private money anything else is simply degrading the public system that we all rely on. We need to move to a more Finnish approach and get ride of private schools altogether. Rather than starving the public system. We need ro remember that public schools are producing the next generation of citizens who more than ever need critical thinking skills and problem solving skills.
Universal healthcare connects people and creates a sense of community. Privatisation drives alienation - b/c it says, in effect, ‘no-one cares about you; without wealth, you don't matter’.
Wow, Deidre! I sat down last night after summarizing my last year of writing and how it has shaped and reshaped me. I pushed that essay out this morning and then I read yours! I can’t help but think we’ve all hit a wall called the UCP FU; we’ll do whatever we want despite what the general populace says! I have not lost my fight, but I am tired of all the BS. Keep it up! I’m listening!
I appreciate your discussion on Smith’s “radicalization” of Albertans. If Dr. Parks is a strong, dedicated supporter of the cause of public, universal, free high quality, healthcare- adequately resourced, he is partisan. He warns we all should be unwilling to consider the alternative where those who can pay get preferential access. Smith is right- he is partisan to the cause of universal healthcare.
She’s the one who made this issue partisan by refusing to listen and adjust policy. Now the only way to influence government policy is to change the government.
Exactly … word for word.
Very well said 👏👏👏
100% agree! The UCP is a hot mess and getting messier. At this point the NDP is the best we’ve got. Dr. Parks just made it an even better choice in my opinion. He’s a hero. Thanks for your honesty and smart writing. I always look forward to seeing you in my inbox Deirdre
Demonstrating "an institutional unwillingness to correct its own course" is the best description of this UCP that I have ever heard. Have they ever once admitted fault? And I don't count mealy-mouthed apologies like the one from "Spanky" McAllister.
I don’t think any of them wanted the job for the sake of responsibility…
Well that's a certainty. Lol
I agree with you 100% there is only one way out now and that is the NDP, otherwise Alberta is doomed if Danielle Smith and the UCP are not defeated.
I agree! Thanks for spelling out your path to this truth!
🙌 agreed whole heartedly - and the current machinations with the map and the laissez faire approach to this much gerrymandering proves this UCP government- literally through 140million dollars in the garbage. They have no intention of changing course, or listening to the citizenry of Alberta.