Anytime education and the ucp come up in the same sentence my mind wanders to the Talibangelicals home schooling and now granting degrees.
I recall once reading a significant difference between an English and a North American education.
North Americans are streamed into pathways. The English go to school to read and be broadened. Exposed to thoughts, concepts, philosophies, science, wonder and curiosity.
So to the ucp reduction and broadened prospects. Perhaps I should have studied more because I’m pretty damn sure reduction lessens choice.
But then again I don’t see the world through dystopian ucp eyes.
at this point malicious stupidity is a compliment because only Smith can be this monumentally stupid as to think this is enough to get moderate voters back on her side
Do you know how many houses in my neighbourhood I walk by with signs about wanting change in approach to education or just generally wanting proper funding to Public education?
Spoiler it’s more than I can count on my two hands so ya at this point it’s either she is this stupid or genuinely this out of touch, take your pick people
Lowering the bar is never good. I taught high school for 32 years here in Alberta. It’s too bad that under continuous conservative governments, other experiences like shops and many other hands on forms of non-academic education that could lead to apprenticeships or tech college were taken out of schools. I doubt if they’ll pay for them to return. So, it appears their ideas for ‘choice’ will be more book learning. That’ll keep students busy, eh?
I won't lift a brain cell to disagree its "fucking awful leadership". But I'm more aggravated that it might be taken for "brilliant politics" - Brilliant p'raps for her stunned dumber than a cut calf in springtime base. But I think most parents, hell most citizens, are going to be pissed right off the bend at the sheer short-sighted stupidity.
Sure, there are some students (and some parents) that are fine with paying less to get less and all that damned fool book larnin' ain't worth a hill of beans - most will muddle through, some will excel beyond all expectations and the dismal bottom set the bar for all sorts of horror.
To water it all down serves no one in the long run - how on earth will Alberta students be ready for what awaits them?
Smith et al are all in for feels that a majority of Alberta students will become super-motivated auto-didacts and just self-service themselves into competence, in some magical hocus-pocus act of libertarian-informed educational boot strapping. Positively Randian in its breathless fantastical ignorance.
Its another act of spectacular un-governing. They have to go.
I was more referring to their ability to reduce their obligations under the guise of choice. For people who recoil from responsibility as much as they do, I am impressed by how easily they manage to sell bad policy to people who support them.
If the Smith government wants “choice” to mean anything, they should publish a clear guarantee that every high school can deliver the courses needed for university, apprenticeship, and direct employment—and fund that promise accordingly.
Anytime education and the ucp come up in the same sentence my mind wanders to the Talibangelicals home schooling and now granting degrees.
I recall once reading a significant difference between an English and a North American education.
North Americans are streamed into pathways. The English go to school to read and be broadened. Exposed to thoughts, concepts, philosophies, science, wonder and curiosity.
So to the ucp reduction and broadened prospects. Perhaps I should have studied more because I’m pretty damn sure reduction lessens choice.
But then again I don’t see the world through dystopian ucp eyes.
at this point malicious stupidity is a compliment because only Smith can be this monumentally stupid as to think this is enough to get moderate voters back on her side
Do you know how many houses in my neighbourhood I walk by with signs about wanting change in approach to education or just generally wanting proper funding to Public education?
Spoiler it’s more than I can count on my two hands so ya at this point it’s either she is this stupid or genuinely this out of touch, take your pick people
Problem is those voters in your neighbourhood will be largely disenfranchised by gerrymandering.
Ya trust me I’m aware
Poor education breeds maga in my opinion
Yup
Lowering the bar is never good. I taught high school for 32 years here in Alberta. It’s too bad that under continuous conservative governments, other experiences like shops and many other hands on forms of non-academic education that could lead to apprenticeships or tech college were taken out of schools. I doubt if they’ll pay for them to return. So, it appears their ideas for ‘choice’ will be more book learning. That’ll keep students busy, eh?
The UCP just want to dumb our children down so they vote UCP when they turn 18 I guess
And how long will it be until they suggest they only will fund “mandatory” courses - now they have made some critical courses optional?
Just one answer I wish I had..
I won't lift a brain cell to disagree its "fucking awful leadership". But I'm more aggravated that it might be taken for "brilliant politics" - Brilliant p'raps for her stunned dumber than a cut calf in springtime base. But I think most parents, hell most citizens, are going to be pissed right off the bend at the sheer short-sighted stupidity.
Sure, there are some students (and some parents) that are fine with paying less to get less and all that damned fool book larnin' ain't worth a hill of beans - most will muddle through, some will excel beyond all expectations and the dismal bottom set the bar for all sorts of horror.
To water it all down serves no one in the long run - how on earth will Alberta students be ready for what awaits them?
Smith et al are all in for feels that a majority of Alberta students will become super-motivated auto-didacts and just self-service themselves into competence, in some magical hocus-pocus act of libertarian-informed educational boot strapping. Positively Randian in its breathless fantastical ignorance.
Its another act of spectacular un-governing. They have to go.
I was more referring to their ability to reduce their obligations under the guise of choice. For people who recoil from responsibility as much as they do, I am impressed by how easily they manage to sell bad policy to people who support them.
I concur - as DEVO said many years ago, to a quite a peppy beat - “Freedom of choice is what you want. Freedom from choice is what you get”.
The UCP world view is such a dismal dystopian hellscape.
If the Smith government wants “choice” to mean anything, they should publish a clear guarantee that every high school can deliver the courses needed for university, apprenticeship, and direct employment—and fund that promise accordingly.
As I commented on Vince Hill’s excellent post on this topic, The enshitification of life in Alberta continues unabated under the UCP.
I think the problems go even further than what you mention here. Any presentation of "choice" without funding will inevitably lead to staffing cuts. This is how you cut teachers at rural public schools without saying you are cutting teachers: https://teachingunderduress.substack.com/p/student-choice-or-how-i-learned-to?r=218ls7
Love the personal journey and reflections. Important questions we need to ask as well.